NYPD Crackdown on Lewdness and Exposure in Penn Station, Grand Central
& other Public Bathrooms
Recently, the Wall Street Journal reported about increased policing of
public bathrooms in New York City. This is part of an ongoing effort by
the City of New York to reduce behavior considered to be lewd and indecent.
Historically, certain public gathering places in New York City have become
popular places for men looking to have sex with or expose themselves to
other men. These places have often contained a certain desirable qualities
such as the seclusion of the Brambles in Central Park, or convenience
such as certain transit hubs. Of the transportation hubs, Penn Station
and Grand Central are especially popular due to their size and proximity
to subway and regional trains. Police officers, in plain clothing, will
enter bathrooms in Penn Station and Grand Central looking for men who
seem to be taking an unusual time at a urinal and/or who are looking over
the urinal divider or exposing themselves. If the undercover sees this,
he will continue his observations to see if the exposure seems deliberate
and if he sees any indications of masturbation which are necessary for
an arrest for lewdness. The undercovers are also looking for blatant sexual
activity between men in the bathrooms at Penn Station and Grand Central.
Although more rare than exposure and masturbation at a urinal due to the
increased risk of being caught, it has been known to happen. Sometimes
groups of men are arrested for sex in these bathrooms. The Wall Street
Journal also pointed out the risk of being falsely accused. This is because
in the case of suspected masturbation in a urinal, the movements and degree
of exposure is different in every case. In some situations, someone struggling
to urinate or too casual about keeping himself close to the urinal may
be accidentally accused of masturbation or intentional exposure.
WSJ Article (2017):
https://www.wsj.com/articles/port-authority-bathroom-arrests-spur-lawsuit-1490648449
By Lance Fletcher
NYC Criminal Defense Attorney